An economic analysis of water use in the Scotland river basin district

An economic analysis of water use in the Scotland river basin district

SUMMARY REPORT

SEPA :: Home Page

spacer
Contents Page Contents Page
Previous Page Previous Page
Next Page Next Page
spacer
spacer   spacer
 

3.3 Abstraction and flow regulation

Many manufacturing processes such as distilling, food processing, and paper and pulp production need to abstract water to produce goods. Water flow is also regulated and abstracted to supply drinking water, to produce hydropower and for navigational purposes. These types of activities may impact on the water environment. The Directive recognises that the benefits of such uses need to be retained and allows water bodies to be designated as heavily modified water bodies (HMWB) where substantial physical alterations have been made to support these uses.

Compared to many other European countries Scotland generally has sufficient supplies of water but the demand on our water supplies continues to increase. This context has meant that pressures arising from abstraction and flow regulation have not been comprehensively regulated in Scotland before now. As a result, limited quantitative information is available and the risk assessment has relied to a large extent on predicted impacts arising from water abstraction or flow regulation.

Figure 7 and Table 10 below show the distribution of pressures caused by abstraction and flow regulation for all water bodies at risk.

Figure 7 Abstraction and flow risk sectors

figure 7

 

Table 10 Abstraction and flow risk sectors

Main Industrial Groups Abstraction Number of Pressures Flow Regulation Total
Energy and Water 363 397 760
Agriculture, Forestry and Fishing 71 30 101
Not identified 0 80 80
Manufacturing 42 2 44
Other 18 11 29
Transport and communications 6 19 25
Mining and quarrying 9 0 9
Sewage and refuse disposal 0 1 1
Total 509 540 1049


The following table illustrates (where data are available) three measures for each of these sectors. GVA 2001 (Gross Value Added) is a measure of the value of the sector to the economy; value of use is presented in pence per cubic metre and volume of use in cubic metres per year

Table 11 Contribution to the Scottish economy and value/volume of water use in sectors connected with abstraction and flow regulation

Abstraction & Flow Regulation Sector GVA 200131 Sub-sector Value of use32 p/m3* Volume of use33 Million m3/year
Agriculture, forestry
and fishing
£827m Agriculture 23-138 irrigation benefits 56.5
Fishing £207m @ Scottish ports £260m Aquaculture only 0.011 to 0.126 1,582
Manufacturing Food & Drink £2,271m Food processing including whisky and soft drinks 12.5 food
21 beverage
260
£516m Textiles 4 1.8
PP&P £1339m Paper & pulp 16 87.7
Energy and water supply Coke/ refining/ nuclear £143m Oil 15 refined petroleum and coal 15
Elec, Gas Water Supply £2,021m Electricity hydro 0.00 to 0.8234 Est total thro’put 23,755
Elec, Gas Water Supply £2,021m Electricity non-hydro n/a (Est storage 3,355)
Mains 6
Fresh 5
Sea 3,772
Total 3,783
t/o £958.3 million 2003/04 Water supply+ n/a 876

+ Scottish Water figures
* p/m3 = Pence per cubic metre


From this table it is clear that the volumes are considerable and that as a consequence of this, the value per cubic metre is low. Given the differing assessment methodologies adopted (as a result of data limitations) it is not meaningful to calculate a sector ‘total’ value of water use figure.


31 http://www.statistics.gov.uk/downloads/theme_economy/Final_SIC_for_GVA_by_region_1989-2001.xls

32 http://www.sepa.org.uk/wfd/stake/eas economics of water use research project (Tables 9.3 and 11.1)

33 http://www.sepa.org.uk/wfd/stake/eas 2004 est (from Dynamics of use)

34 Scottish and Southern Energy, from personal correspondence, consider this a significant underestimate with their internal calculations giving values up to 5.2p

 
spacer
spacer
Contents Page Contents Page
Previous Page Previous Page
Next Page Next Page
spacer